Best Butter Chicken Pizza in Winnipeg

(63 reviews)

One of the most-searched fusion pizzas in Winnipeg, our Butter Chicken Pizza layers tender chicken in a rich, creamy makhani sauce over a cheesy crust. It's the comfort of a classic Punjabi butter chicken curry reimagined as a pizza, and it's one of City South Pizza's most popular signature pies.

Signature Fusion Pizza

Spice Level: Mild-Medium

Customer Favorite

Order Now

Butter Chicken Pizza topped with creamy makhani chicken sauce and melted cheese at City South Pizza in Winnipeg

About Our Butter Chicken Pizza

We start with the same butter chicken sauce used in our curries - a velvety tomato and cream base infused with butter and warm spices - and spread it generously across our fresh dough instead of a traditional tomato sauce.

Tender chicken pieces simmered in that makhani gravy are then loaded onto the crust with a blend of melted cheeses and baked fresh. The result is creamy, mildly spiced, and absolutely craveable - it's easy to see why people search 'butter chicken pizza near me' and land on City South Pizza.

What Makes Our Butter Chicken Pizza Special

Rich, creamy butter chicken (makhani) sauce base
Tender chicken simmered in makhani gravy
Topped with a blend of melted cheeses
Mild spice, family-friendly flavor
One of our best-selling fusion pizzas

What Customers Say About Our Butter Chicken Pizza

Chris N.

Winnipeg Resident

"Butter Chicken Pizza is genius. Creamy, saucy, and the chicken is so tender. Ordered it for a family dinner and everyone wanted more."

March 2026

Nav K.

Regular Customer

"I searched 'butter chicken pizza near me' and this place came up - so glad it did. Best fusion pizza I've had in Winnipeg, hands down."

February 2026

Emily R.

First-time Visitor

"This was my first time trying City South Pizza and the Butter Chicken Pizza did not disappoint. Rich, flavorful, and generous toppings."

January 2026

Ready to Try Our Butter Chicken Pizza?

Order online for pickup or delivery throughout north Winnipeg, or visit us on McPhillips St

Order Now View Full Menu

Visit Us in Winnipeg

Address

2501 McPhillips St
Winnipeg, MB R2V 4M3, Canada

Phone

(204) 594-7771

Hours

Mon–Thu & Sun: 11:00 AM – 12:00 AM
Fri–Sat: 11:00 AM – 1:00 AM

Get Directions Order Online